Building Safety and Security by Tackling Marginalization

This post is part of our Community Safety and Security series, focused on sharing the approaches and tools TCU uses to create our community spaces, including the Global Gathering. Rather than reinventing the wheel, this series highlights the people, ideas, and frameworks that have influenced our work and shaped how we think about community safety and security. TCU is known for its code of conduct (COC) and its trauma-informed COC implementation process, as well as our equity and security tools, protocols, and approaches that center the most impacted by surveillance and censorship.

The following blog post highlights the guidance, wisdom and inspiration we received from Dalit women, afro-diaspora women from the Americas, LGBTQI+ folks, and De|Center’s methodology “design from the margins.” The staff at De|Center also helped us better share our story in this post.


The Start: Creating an Inclusive Space

Designing from the Margins

When you are marginalized, the world is not set up with your needs in mind. Some individuals find themselves constantly adjusting to it, gradually becoming alienated from their true self as they reshape their persona to navigate a reality that was never designed for them. Over time, individuals begin to show up as only a fraction of who they are. It is a gradual loss of self and identity. It also takes something else: the ability to share with the world their wisdom, perspective, and talents.

As one community member shared, “For many of us who are part of marginalized communities and who were present in the early days of digital rights and open source, the tragedy was not simply that we felt excluded or unsafe in many of the existing spaces. We also felt compelled to abandon, diminish, and constantly translate who we were in order to belong. The pervasive lack of safety meant keeping our voices behind lock and key, regardless of how often the words freedom or libre were invoked.”

This is how the Global Gathering began. Rather than continuing to fight for inclusion in spaces that were never designed with marginalized folks in mind, we asked a different question: What if, instead of begging to be included, we created a space where marginalized communities were included by default? What would it look like to build something that not only welcomed them, but was designed from the outset to recognize their needs, experiences, knowledge, and ways of being?

The truth is, when we began, we had more questions than answers and a great deal to learn. But we had something that carried us forward: an unwavering commitment to the possibility of something different. With that conviction, we set out on a journey that would span years, learning -stumbling, adapting, and discovering along the way - what it really means to build a space where people feel safe and secure to show up as their whole selves.

The Wisdom of Lived Experience

Being young comes with a unique opportunity - you believe anything is possible. You have the passion, the conviction, and the audacity to imagine something different, even when you lack the experience, resources, or skills to bring it to life. As Pablo Coelho more sweetly puts it

“Everyone, when they are young. . . everything is clear and everything is possible.”


When we first opened our doors, we didn't fully understand how marginalization manifests differently across communities, identities, and geographies. Thankfully, our capacity to listen was as strong as our passion. We began learning what marginalization meant to people in different parts of the world. 

Among our many teachers were Dalit women, afro-diaspora women from the Americas, and LGBTQI+ folks living in places where it is illegal to be themselves, all of whom shared their profound wisdom, rooted in their lived experiences and struggles. These communities have been pioneers in developing approaches to community care and resistance, as well as critical frameworks for understanding how oppression operates and how different forms of oppression intersect to produce societal violence. The progress they have fought, and continue to fight for, has benefited countless communities around the world, even if they have yet to receive the recognition they deserve.

Of course, other groups contributed to our understanding and have also done their part to advance equity and liberation in the world but, for us, these three groups were especially important teachers. 

They helped shape our understanding of marginalization as well as our implementation strategy, reminding us that meaningful progress requires more than theoretical debates—it demands practical action grounded in what was actually possible given our capacity and resources. This and many other lessons would take us years to fully embody.

Perhaps the most important thing they offered was their unwavering support. They understood the struggles we would encounter as we worked to bring our vision to life, and the personal cost that would come with it. They also provided us with words to explain what we were going through, which was by far the most powerful. One thing is to be marginalized, another is to be part of a group that has endured it for centuries in societies where rules and systems are constantly changing tactics to further reduce visibility of these groups and therefore possibilities for support. These groups carry with them generations of knowledge about how oppression operates, how it is internalized, and what are its consequences.

Marginalization in Digital Rights: What We Tackled

During these early years, we began to develop a more concrete understanding of the forms of marginalization we were trying to address. They included:

 

⚖️ Socioeconomic Marginalization:

While the digital rights field is international, a significant proportion of its participants come from middle- and upper-income backgrounds, regardless of their country of origin. We saw this as part of a larger issue where the barrier and costs to access for those not from these socio-economic backgrounds were too high.

This was among the many reasons we have always offered free tickets, trying to put into practice the value of, "If it's inaccessible to the poor, it's neither radical nor revolutionary." This is difficult to do for numerous reasons, but we did what we could within the constraints we faced. We knew access to these spaces also frames who gets projects, networks, funds, and who doesn’t. 

We also developed numerous mentorship opportunities as well as our well-regarded Equity Fund, which provides financial, security, and visa assistance to those from truly low-income contexts, especially from the Global Majority. We continue to work hard to put emphasis in getting these resources for the community. 

These offerings were also especially designed with new folks in mind, particularly those that had never traveled outside their country, attended an international conference, or found themselves in spaces where they could envision themselves as leaders. Some also experienced varying degrees of imposter syndrome. Helping them recognize that the Global Gathering was a space built for them, and that their voices and leadership belonged there, became paramount.

Since its start, we aimed for the Equity Fund to represent around 25% of our conference budget, and every year we work hard to increase it, with some years being better than others. Before the pandemic and historic funding cuts, we were supporting around 120 people on average.

Our mentorship programs have evolved over time, reflecting the changing needs of our community, but have consistently focused on strengthening the leadership of those historically underrepresented in the field. As our fellows grew into leaders in the field and more diverse leadership began to emerge across the sector, our approach to mentorship shifted. We increasingly focused on connecting people with one another, fostering collaboration, and creating opportunities for collective growth and leadership. 

In recent years, we have begun to see a renewed need for fellowship opportunities, and we are working to bring them back

♀️ Gender:

 In the early years, women and gender-nonconforming people were significantly underrepresented in digital rights and, consequently, in many of its spaces. Addressing this imbalance meant more than simply increasing their participation; it meant creating an environment where they could contribute, lead, and feel a sense of safety and belonging. 

This prompted us to develop and implement a Code of Conduct (CoC) and equity tools that were subsequently adapted by many groups in the digital rights space and beyond. Among our contributions was developing a CoC process that was led by mental health professionals.

Implementing and perfecting a CoC was arduous and painful. The pushback we received was intense and consistent. However, a large percentage of people from marginalized communities, particularly those who had experienced a lot of harm, made it a point to express their appreciation and approval, which ultimately provided us with the strength to go forward.

Another major challenge was the nature of the CoC reports themselves These varied considerably in scope and severity, ranging from sexual violence and workplace harassment to overt racism and substance abuse. Recognizing the complexity and sensitivity of these cases, we began engaging mental health professionals to help oversee the process. Even then, finding the right professionals—people with the experience and understanding to work with at-risk communities and individuals from marginalized contexts—proved far more complicated than it might seem. 

To complement the CoC, we also organized numerous allyship workshops, which played an important role in building awareness, educating participants, and helping shift the culture of the field. We saw meaningful progress within our own community spaces and, to some extent, across the wider digital rights ecosystem. These workshops created opportunities for difficult but necessary conversations, not only among people from marginalized communities, but also among those who hold greater privilege and are often less accustomed to engaging with these issues. Creating space to listen, reflect, and learn became an important part of our broader equity work. 

🧩 Racial, Ethnic, and Sexual Identity:

One thing people often overlook is that racism and discrimination exist everywhere, though they take on different forms and carry different meanings depending on the social, cultural, and historical context. The hierarchies they create also vary and manifest differently, shaping who holds power and how marginalization is experienced. As an example, one African community member shared, “In my country, I am not reminded that I’m black on a daily basis.” While another Black woman from the Americas shared that she was surprised she was perceived as white when she traveled to Ghana.

Working with a global and expansive community, particularly activists, it was vital for us to learn and teach others that marginalization cannot be understood simply through a Global North-Global South lens. While this divide reflects profound power imbalances, and the enduring violence of colonization, and remains particularly visible in many contexts, it does not tell the whole story.

We must also recognize that marginalization exists within every society and community, and these dynamics also bubble into community spaces we are building. 

We heard from numerous people who felt unsafe and unwelcomed within their own communities, including within both emerging and established local digital rights networks, whether from layers of stigma, marginalization, or even criminalization. 

Their experiences reminded us that exclusion and discrimination are not confined to particular geographies or political systems, and that international spaces must also contend with the power dynamics and inequalities that exist both within our own field and local communities. 

There is one particular story we still share. During one gathering that took place outside of South Asia, we noticed that several Dalit women kept isolating themselves, and were barely engaging. When we approached them to understand what was happening, they explained that they were concerned about a male participant they did not know, who they perceived to be South Asian, and were unsure whether he was safe. We soon realized that for the women, understanding whether other South Asians in the room supported caste-liberation, or were anti-caste was essentially for their sense of safety. 

Dalit communities are the most marginalized caste primarily in India and across the South Asian diaspora. In India alone, an estimated 200 million Dalit face systematic and extreme incidents of  discrimination, violence and severe economic hardship, driven by widespread impunity.  Violence against Dalit people happens everywhere in the world, but this type of discrimination is not as understood outside of certain circles. As an example, caste-based discrimination against Dalit people is a major issue in  Silicon Valley, but was only brought to light because of high-profile legal battles and civil rights campaigns run by Dalit communities themselves.

This story stayed with us because it helped us understand just how deeply fear can be shaped by people's experiences in their local contexts—and how those experiences can travel with them into spaces that are meant to offer something different.  This incident provided us with a deeper understanding of marginalization that ultimately helped us better strengthen our safety strategy.

 
marginalization exists within every society and community

An Understanding of Different Elements of Intersectionality Can Help You Identify What Areas of Marginalization are More Prevalent

Intersectionality, and its many elements, can help you understand what areas marginalization are more prevalent in your community and worth your investment. This is the work of understanding how different social and political identities interact, overlap, and collectively create unique experiences in systems of oppression or privilege. Coined by Kimberlé Crenshaw, she makes it a point to stress that it's not identity politics on steroids. Rather, she describes it as, “a lens, a prism, for seeing the way in which various forms of inequality often operate together and exacerbate each other.”

While the term was originally rooted in domestic legal systems, scholars have expanded intersectionality into a global, anti-colonial tool. They analyze how systemic oppression, state power, and structural privilege overlap to create unique material realities. 

Giants like Angela Davis also demonstrate that local inequalities are deeply connected to global struggles, linking domestic, systemic racism directly to international issues like the military occupation, war, environmental violence, and corporate exploitation.  

Applying these frameworks to your community work means analyzing who populates your community, identifying how global and local structures uniquely alienate and risk specific groups, and how to be active in resilience with them while building pathways and learning with them. More on how to do this in an equitable way down below. 

Employing an intersectionality lens allowed us to bring in really creative ways to allow communities to do advocacy and be present in our spaces. It also continues to bring depth to digital rights work that is hard to see in other spaces, while enhancing how we see joy from all angles.


Honing The Strategy 

A few years into our journey, as we began to hone our strategy, LGBTQI+ dating apps started emerging as an important topic of conversation in our field thanks to the pioneering work done by Afsaneh Rigot, Founder and Principal Researcher at De|Center, who had been conducting research with experts and victims in some of the key countries where use of queer dating apps and other communication tools have been used to criminalize queer people.  These conversations shed light on the particular vulnerabilities queer people faced while traveling, especially in places where their identities could put their safety at risk. Using this research, Rigot began developing a methodology, which she coined Designing from the Margins, to show why building with the most marginalized and criminalized users in mind from the start results in better tech for everyone. This methodology helped us recognize that our own approach could benefit from greater structure and methodological rigor.

Most importantly, it helped us understand that threats often remain “unseen” by institutions and those in positions of privilege.

In our next post, we will be sharing how this methodology helped us improve our strategy, and better see security and safety threats.

The Practical: How You Can Do It

There are many ways that you can support the most marginalized in your community to better understand their security and safety needs. The first step is to listen and have humility. Be ready to have your preconceptions tested. This can take many forms, from one-to-one conversations to group feedback sessions. What matters is creating opportunities for people to share their experience openly and honestly. 

1. Establish Long Term Relationships 🤝

Creating healthy relationships with members of your community requires understanding that these relationships are not transactional. Rather, think of them like long-term commitments that should nurture and support both sides. Authentic trust is required to better understand the complexities and nuances of each person and group within your network. Without this trust, you will miss half the story, as sharing safety and security concerns can be a vulnerable act.

2. Provide Practical, Valued Support 🛠️

Listening is the first step, but taking action is another. If people feel that progress is not being made, they may ultimately decide that investing in your community space is not worthwhile. We are all operating on tight budgets, and sometimes certain things simply aren’t possible. But this means getting creative about how to achieve particular goals (for example, bartering with others when resources are unavailable) or being transparent about what you can and can't do, and why. 

3. Accept That You Cannot Create an Equity Paradise, Even Though You Should Always Strive Toward One ⚖️

As much as we should continue striving for greater equity, perfection is not possible. People often underestimate the real investment required to create the conditions for safety and security, whether that investment comes in the form of time, money, or both. You cannot be everything to everyone, and even in the best-case scenarios, meaningful changes take time to develop. 

Years ago, we wanted to increase the representation of indigenous people from Latin America in our community spaces, particularly because of their environmental and land rights work. We consulted a Latin American community member who had decades of experience working with Indigenous groups. Their advice? We weren’t ready to receive this group of people. There was still significant work to be done around safety and security, and we weren’t yet equipped to provide the support they needed. 

That lesson stayed with us. Over the years, we continue working toward those specific goals, and have seen strong progress, including higher indigenous representation at our in-person event than ever before. However, accepting that proper cultivation of specific groups will take time and the proper investment is paramount to safety and security.

4. Avoid Extraction and Harmful Trends 🚫

There is an increasing tendency for organizations and community spaces to adopt the language of equity without doing the work required to make those commitments meaningful, and causing more harm in the process. This can lead to practices that are more performative than substantive, where marginalized people are invited into spaces to provide their perspectives, share their experiences, or improve representation, but receive little in return, or in the worst case scenario, be harmed for doing so. 

Are you asking people to share deeply personal or potentially sensitive experiences without offering anything meaningful in return? Are you inviting people to participate because their presence strengthens your metrics or public image? Are you borrowing (and in some cases stealing) ideas, knowledge, and expertise without recognizing the people who contributed them?

These extractive practices reinforce the very power imbalances that organizations claim to be challenging.

Meaningful engagement requires reciprocity. This means recognizing people's time, expertise, and contributions, compensating them whenever possible, giving credit where it is due, and respecting their boundaries. It also means resisting the temptation to follow every emerging trend or adopt language simply because it is popular. Instead, focus on understanding what communities actually need and developing approaches that are grounded in their lived experiences. Ultimately, marginalized communities should not have to continually educate, validate, or legitimize the work of organizations that claim to support them. They should be valued as partners, knowledge holders, and decision-makers in shaping the spaces they participate in.

For us, a major change was significantly reducing volunteers post-pandemic, despite numerous offers from community members and the volunteer culture of the open source community. Given the financial precarity of the space in recent years, accepting free help from marginalized individuals, particularly those that can not do it under the hat of an organization that they are employed with, feels harmful to us. This may change if the financial climate changes, but for now, we prioritize paying those that help us, even if it's a small contribution. 

5. Accept its An Ongoing Process And The Work Never Stops 🔄

What works today may not work tomorrow, and what feels safe and welcoming to one group may not feel that way to another. You have to be willing to listen when people tell you something isn't working, even when that feedback is uncomfortable or challenges the way you've been doing things.

It's easy to become attached to the structures, processes, and community culture you've spent years building. But sometimes those very structures can create barriers for the people you're trying to reach. Rather than becoming defensive, take feedback as an opportunity to reflect, reassess, and make changes where possible.

However, here is the caveat—prioritize feedback from those groups that are the most marginalized. Sometimes the loudest voice in the room is not representative of those you are trying to accommodate.

Next
Next

The Global Gathering 2026 Report Published!